It's difficult to say 100% who I would offer new contracts to without knowing what league we'll be in, but some are incredibly easy renewal decisions.
Agyei - Offer a 2+1 and hope. I don't think the issues with Agyei are as bad as they're displayed on here, but if another L1 club offers him the number 9 shirt and regular starts he may just take it. His big advantage with us is Taylor isn't getting any younger so possibly he sees himself taking that spot one day soon.
Bodin - Depends purely on his fitness. If he manages 25-30 odd appearances this year then offer him another year. If he spends more time in the treatment room than on the pitch let him go.
LCP - Has an option of another year that we should 100% take - and potentially after activating start thinking about another 1+1 deal. The lad's got real talent.
Elechi - Still only 19 so doesn't affect the squad cap and I still think there's something in there. I'd offer a 1 year contract, but if we go up I can't see him challenging for a spot in the Championship so it might be better to let him move on to get regular games.
Forde - Probably the trickiest one. A really good utility player - but not exceptional in any of the positions he plays at this level. If we're in L1 next year I'd give him another year, but wouldn't be too upset if he moved on for more regular football.
Goodrham - Easiest decision on the list for me. He's got a year option, activate that then immediately look at offering another year on top of that with an option of another. This lad looks special and I think the only thing that will stop him making the first team is if someone above us snatches him up first.
Gorrin - Offer 2 year contract. Easy one.
Hanson - Unfortunately it's not worked out at all for Hanson. Let him go so he can try and make a career for himself in L2.
Henry - Doesn't matter what league we're in, Henry has to stay. 50 goals in under 200 games and still a huge influence on our team. Offer a 1+1 and if he wants to get into coaching let him follow the Mous path too. Brilliant player who we've been lucky to have with us for 5 years, and hopefully more to come.
Moore - I really fear Moore will delay to see what league we're in and if we don't go up he'll move on. Hopefully we can strike a deal with him where if he signs an extension and we don't go up, there's a release clause of 7 figures. Off a 2 year deal and pray he signs.
Spasov - Looked like a real prospect but injuries have been an issue and he's not progressed at the rate I'd have hoped. Get him out on loan and see how he does, if he looks good offer a 1+1, if not let him go.
Sykes - Started the season brilliantly and I think he's starting to find some consistency too. Final product hopefully will come now he's got that crucial first goal. Offer a 3 year deal.
Winnall - I've been less critical than most of Winnall, but I just don't think he's up to the standard of a promotion chasing L1 club so we have to let him go. A big wage that can be given to someone younger, fitter and more clinical.
Loanees - pretty sure we have options on Holland and Thornily. Thornily is a 100% sign on a perm if we do, Holland I'm yet to be convinced. Whyte and Kane if we have the chance to sign we should but I think it's probably unlikely unless we go up this year.
Tldr:
Offer contracts - Agyei, LCP, Goodrham, Gorrin, Henry, Moore, Sykes, Thornily
Maybes - Bodin, Elechi, Forde, Spasov, Holland
Let go - Hanson, Winnall