I personally don't live in the local area around the stadium so not really for me to say! Obviously you have the created jobs, but I suppose beyond that it all depends on the details of what is actually going to be around the stadium. They've referred to 'outdoor community' spaces and 'multi-functional plazas', but haven't gone into much detail about what those spaces will actually have within them. I would assume things like bars, restaurants, shops but I don't know enough about the layout and facilities already in/around Kidlington to say whether they're actually needed or in demand. I can only say for certain how it'll effect me as an Oxford fan not living in or on the outskirts of Kidlington.
Obviously it's good for sport in the local area, with funding being put into local sports teams by the club (although again, it's unclear how much or how it'll be funded), and obviously it's a good thing for football fans countywide. I really like the idea of the club developing mental health outreach programmes within the community, and that the stadium and it's facilities can be used by the local and wider community for various events and purposes. Would love to see mini-tournaments for all ages ran on the main pitch (like they've done at Southampton).
I've never doubted or denied there are positives to the plans, I've merely just raised concerns about details, clarity, and whether some claims made are feasible.
I think that's fair enough, no?