We can only judge by a) How they played against us, and b) the stats.....
.....but based on those things, actually I've not got too many complaints about that team. Other than the ridiculous part about having an out-and-out winger at left back. Did noone in League One have any decent fullbacks this year?
Cooper was absolutely outstanding both games against us, and only Rotherham have conceded less goals than Plymouth, and they've used two keepers roughly evenly.
The guy who probably has the most grounds for complaint is not Cole Stockton, but Will Keane.
Joint top scorer in the League, playing for the Champions elect, most Goals per 90 and assists of any of the striking options.
It's a sign of the quality in the league this year, that Matty Taylor has had a great season, but has probably only been the 5th or 6th best striker in the division.