Did ok for the first 30 minutes, but just lost it from then on. Seemed to have sympathy for Charlton at times, and yet also booked 6 and sent one off too! Inconsistent, and card happy.
However, I DID really like how when he wasn't 100% sure he went to his other officials and spoke to them about what they saw. A few too many refs at this level try to run it all themselves, so that was good to see. A 5 feels generous, but we just won emphatically so it's what he's got.