Ref Watch Oxford utd v Maidenhead Utd FA Cup 1 4/11/2023 Dale Baines

[Sarge]

Had a decent game and was fairly consistent , this nat league ref was better than quite a number of l1 refs

7 from me

 

[Manorlounger]

Possibly a penalty when Tyler Goodrham was through and definitely let a lot of shirt pulling go. Really bugs me, the shirt pulling. It's cheating and should be penalised but, it just goes on and on.

 

[m]

Had a decent game and was fairly consistent , this nat league ref was better than quite a number of l1 games

7 from m

That's a little presumptuous, Sarge.

 

[Sarge]

That's a little presumptuous, Sarge.

Oops ...edited

 

[ZeroTheHero]

Fine. I'm not convinced the tackle on Goodrham should have been pen - and I actually think he handled it anyway! He played advantage well a couple of times, wasn't overly picky and didn't try to make himself the centre of attention. If we had refs of this and Tuesday's standard every game, I think we'd be happier than we often are with the officiate.

 

[Marked Ox]

Fine. I'm not convinced the tackle on Goodrham should have been pen - and I actually think he handled it anyway! He played advantage well a couple of times, wasn't overly picky and didn't try to make himself the centre of attention. If we had refs of this and Tuesday's standard every game, I think we'd be happier than we often are with the officiate.

For me it wasn't a penalty, just a good challenge by their defender.

Decent performance by the Ref, fairly consistent.

 

[bazzer9461]

7 from me as had been said a decent performance and kept the game flowing well moving

 

[GRB]

I watched the game and hardly noticed the ref which generally means he did ok. It wasn't the hardest game to ref though.

 

[m]

I watched the game and hardly noticed the ref which generally means he did ok. It wasn't the hardest game to ref though.

Don't ask me why but I happened to notice that the first free kick wasn't given until the 12th minute. The 2nd came in the 25th.