Ref Watch Oxford United V Charlton.Athletic 29/12/2022 L1 Ben Toner

[Sarge]

Did Ok I thought....maybe couldve been a bit more consistent in decision making ...7 from me

 

[Foley]

Yes pretty good.
He let the game flow. Quite an easy game to control but he got the main decisions right.

 

[YellowSubmarine]

Interesting how referees are viewed when we win.

Thought he was poorer than the Ipswich ref. Thought there was a blatant shirt pull before Charlton scored.

 

[Yellow River]

We won, so I tend to be more lenient to the referee.

However it was not a difficult game to ref, yet was whistle happy particularly in the second half.
Too many soft free kicks.

 

[Northstandboy]

5 from me, as I said in the Match Day Thread, he should have h gave CB a free kick in the second half, after Jack Payne fouled him but was already on a yellow.

Also first half cynical foul player was not carded.

 

[Marked Ox]

Thought he was good. Bar a short spell where they'd fall over and he'd give a free kick whilst ignoring the same on Matty Taylor in the 2nd half, he was consistent which is what I wanted when playing (regardless of if it is the right or wrong decision).

 

[Sarge]

Interesting how referees are viewed when we win.

Thought he was poorer than the Ipswich ref. Thought there was a blatant shirt pull before Charlton scored.

there are generally less opinions cast in the poll when we win ..... and I know I tend to be slightly more generous in my rating for the match official ( there has been the occasional exception though) when we win- the feel good factor after a win does have an effect ( certainly on my ratings)

 

[NorthWestOx]

Missed the blatant assault on Matty, missed the foul on Brannagan.
Apart from that...

 

[bazzer9461]

Gave a 6 didn’t go watch’s on ifollow not overly impressed Payne lucky to still be on and letting a not go between Clare and his robust over the top challenges on Taylor

 

[bazzer9461]

there are generally less opinions cast in the poll when we win ..... and I know I tend to be slightly more generous in my rating for the match official ( there has been the occasional exception ( Kettle and Madden ) when we win- the feel good factor after a win does have an effect ( certainly on my ratings)

Changed that for you @Sarge