Ref Watch Coventry City V Oxford United FA Cup3 6/1/2024 Josh Smith

[Sarge]

rather inconsistant with his yellow cards IMO , gave one of the softest pens Ive seen first few mins of 2nd half, effectively killing the game as a contest. Missed/ ignored the foul on Stevens before the 5th goal. 4 from me

 

[chuckbert]

Homer

 

[Foley]

rather inconsistant with his yellow cards IMO , gave one of the softest pens Ive seen first few mins of 2nd half, effectively killing the game as a contest. Missed/ ignored the foul on Stevens before the 5th goal. 4 from me

RO said the same

 

[ZeroTheHero]

The looked like a pen to me - we would certainly have wanted if it was the other way. I thought he also did us a favour by not giving a second yellow when he probably should have - but then he probably should have given a couple more to Coventry as well. I didn't think he was bad at all (via iFollow). 7 from me (so above average).

 

[Essexyellows]

Poor 3 from me, mostly due to inconsistency in cards and decision making.

 

[Pompeyyellows]

Only a 4 from me. Just felt he favoured Cov a bit to much. Didn’t effect the result though.

 

[Oxford84]

Never a penalty and foul on Stevens for the fifth goal.