Matches Top 6 Race 2023/24

Manning has gone, move on.
Being in the top 6 at this stage of the season is a massive turnaround after last season.
We are in the top 6 and are in with a shout of promotion going in the last few games of the season.

Glad you are finally getting onboard and being positive for once about Des and the team.
If we manage to secure a play off position, the other 3 teams will hope they get us in the semis but as we know anything can happen and we could sneak a win and make the play off final. But first we have to consolidate our position in the play offs starting Good Friday.
 
They’d be crazy not to give him a chance to see what he can do in a new season. We don’t like him, justifiably, but I think he could be a successful manager in time.
Well he has a long way to go to prove that. If and it is an if the BCFC owners decide to gib him another season with a fresh start he may manage that. Had he stayed here he may well have proved himself but going to BCFC he certainly hasn’t.
 
Except for Robinson…

For a few weeks in the aftermath of his departure maybe or when I’m responding to something about him. Robinson has been gone a year and Manning 5 months but there are, unbelievably, people still obsessed with the pair of them. Robinson, in particular, is an odd one. He did a decent job but there are people still bothered by his personal relationships. Who really gives a sh*t what a manager is doing in his own time. Unhealthily obsessed.
 
For a few weeks in the aftermath of his departure maybe or when I’m responding to something about him. Robinson has been gone a year and Manning 5 months but there are, unbelievably, people still obsessed with the pair of them. Robinson, in particular, is an odd one. He did a decent job but there are people still bothered by his personal relationships. Who really gives a sh*t what a manager is doing in his own time. Unhealthily obsessed.
Dick, love what you have written, that’s pure comedy, even funnier than believing The Hunted on Ch4 has any semblance of reality and genuine truth about it.

I needed cheering up and you’ve nailed it 👍
 
For a few weeks in the aftermath of his departure maybe or when I’m responding to something about him. Robinson has been gone a year and Manning 5 months but there are, unbelievably, people still obsessed with the pair of them. Robinson, in particular, is an odd one. He did a decent job but there are people still bothered by his personal relationships. Who really gives a sh*t what a manager is doing in his own time. Unhealthily obsessed.
He did a decent job until his last year where those personal relationships set back the club to the point we needed a complete rebuild, one that we are still going through.
 
He did a decent job until his last year where those personal relationships set back the club to the point we needed a complete rebuild, one that we are still going through.

That’s life, people have personal issues like a marriage breakdown. If that was a mental health problem you’d probably be understanding. Oxford United isn’t life or death, anyone’s personal problems will likely affect their professional life - mine, yours or Karl Robinsons included. It doesn’t make him a bad football manager, when you look at what’s gone on since November, Robinson looks a better manager every passing day.
 
That’s life, people have personal issues like a marriage breakdown. If that was a mental health problem you’d probably be understanding. Oxford United isn’t life or death, anyone’s personal problems will likely affect their professional life - mine, yours or Karl Robinsons included. It doesn’t make him a bad football manager, when you look at what’s gone on since November, Robinson looks a better manager every passing day.

Yet you make no allowance for the significant upheaval and change Des has had to deal with as he gets to grips with a major uptick in his career.
 
Last season has gone. What’s that got to do with it? What are you going to give me next, our match by match XG from the 22/23 season. Move on. Does finishing towards bottom give you a fee hit the season after? On that basis, 18th this season is a success, an improvement. Football moves quickly, massive turnarounds are needed not inch by inch improvements. We had a top budget this season by all accounts, I was definitely expecting promotion or the very least a bloody good go at it.

You were expecting promotion this season? Fair enough after the good start but before a ball was kicked?
 
For a few weeks in the aftermath of his departure maybe or when I’m responding to something about him. Robinson has been gone a year and Manning 5 months but there are, unbelievably, people still obsessed with the pair of them. Robinson, in particular, is an odd one. He did a decent job but there are people still bothered by his personal relationships. Who really gives a sh*t what a manager is doing in his own time. Unhealthily obsessed.

You are having a go at Buckingham for not getting us promoted, yet praising Robinson who in 5 years never got promoted and was getting us relegated had he not got sacked?
 
You were expecting promotion this season? Fair enough after the good start but before a ball was kicked?

Yes, I think so. The budget was top two or three wasn’t it? How many more seasons in L1 is the championship going to be just a distant dream? It can’t go on forever. I thought the recruitment was really good in the summer, everything looked geared up and the start proved it. I don’t think anyone expects anything in football but everything considered, yes, I was expecting us to be knocking on the door of the automatics and a play off place sealed without too much fuss.
 
Yes, I think so. The budget was top two or three wasn’t it? How many more seasons in L1 is the championship going to be just a distant dream? It can’t go on forever. I thought the recruitment was really good in the summer, everything looked geared up and the start proved it. I don’t think anyone expects anything in football but everything considered, yes, I was expecting us to be knocking on the door of the automatics and a play off place sealed without too much fuss.

I doubt it was top two. top 6 maybe. Trouble was a lot of that budget was going on Henry, Browne etc, players on good money who contribute little.
 
Yes, I think so. The budget was top two or three wasn’t it? How many more seasons in L1 is the championship going to be just a distant dream? It can’t go on forever. I thought the recruitment was really good in the summer, everything looked geared up and the start proved it. I don’t think anyone expects anything in football but everything considered, yes, I was expecting us to be knocking on the door of the automatics and a play off place sealed without too much fuss.
I guess this is why you come across as being permanently disappointed and accusatory then. Maybe your expectations were unrealistic to begin with and the structural problems many of us could see were actually the reality.

In the summer, amongst the utter relief of avoiding relegation - just, there was plenty of agreement on here that we needed a major rebuilding job that would take multiple windows (and that was just with the same manager) to sort out, such was the state of the squad Manning, and then Buckingham inherited. Chock full of highly paid players who could not be relied on for more than a dozen games a season, a severely skewed squad, lacking in depth in some fundamental positions on the pitch, other players bombed out and dismantled by a manager who clearly held grudges. A recruitment team that had been largely sidelined by Robinson to massage his own ego as the saviour of Oxford United?

And yet, Manning comes in, manages to get a non-functioning squad to barely function enough and scrape enough points to avoid relegation. Then makes few astute (to his management team and the recruitment teams credit) signings (and some not so, as it turns out) to bolster the squad and with a full pre-season behind them and a settled management team to guide them, get off to an absolute flyer in the league. Then as things settle and the inevitable injuries start to affect the team, the age old problems of no depth become very apparent, coupled with a manager jumping ship when it looks like we might be on to a good thing.

I'm actually pleasantly surprised we are still where we are with it all in our hands and everything to play for, with a squad returning to full strength, bolstered by a few astute January signings (and yes, one or two not so astute) at the business end of the season.

I fully expected just outside the playoffs this year and a push next season, but now ....who knows.

I will enjoy the ride though - hope you do too, Dick!
 
I guess this is why you come across as being permanently disappointed and accusatory then. Maybe your expectations were unrealistic to begin with and the structural problems many of us could see were actually the reality.

In the summer, amongst the utter relief of avoiding relegation - just, there was plenty of agreement on here that we needed a major rebuilding job that would take multiple windows (and that was just with the same manager) to sort out, such was the state of the squad Manning, and then Buckingham inherited. Chock full of highly paid players who could not be relied on for more than a dozen games a season, a severely skewed squad, lacking in depth in some fundamental positions on the pitch, other players bombed out and dismantled by a manager who clearly held grudges. A recruitment team that had been largely sidelined by Robinson to massage his own ego as the saviour of Oxford United?

And yet, Manning comes in, manages to get a non-functioning squad to barely function enough and scrape enough points to avoid relegation. Then makes few astute (to his management team and the recruitment teams credit) signings (and some not so, as it turns out) to bolster the squad and with a full pre-season behind them and a settled management team to guide them, get off to an absolute flyer in the league. Then as things settle and the inevitable injuries start to affect the team, the age old problems of no depth become very apparent, coupled with a manager jumping ship when it looks like we might be on to a good thing.

I'm actually pleasantly surprised we are still where we are with it all in our hands and everything to play for, with a squad returning to full strength, bolstered by a few astute January signings (and yes, one or two not so astute) at the business end of the season.

I fully expected just outside the playoffs this year and a push next season, but now ....who knows.

I will enjoy the ride though - hope you do too, Dick!
"In football anything is possible".
 
That’s life, people have personal issues like a marriage breakdown. If that was a mental health problem you’d probably be understanding. Oxford United isn’t life or death, anyone’s personal problems will likely affect their professional life - mine, yours or Karl Robinsons included. It doesn’t make him a bad football manager, when you look at what’s gone on since November, Robinson looks a better manager every passing day.
The way you go on about Buckingham, you would think it is.
 
Barnsley don't think we will make top 6 on form and PPG since the start of the year, but don't write us off completely.
 
That’s life, people have personal issues like a marriage breakdown. If that was a mental health problem you’d probably be understanding. Oxford United isn’t life or death, anyone’s personal problems will likely affect their professional life - mine, yours or Karl Robinsons included. It doesn’t make him a bad football manager, when you look at what’s gone on since November, Robinson looks a better manager every passing day.

So Karl Robinson, a good manager, gets a squad to finish 19th.

You then expect (largely - due to long contracts) the same squad to get promoted the following season?
 
Back
Top Bottom