Ref Watch 08/05/2024: L1 Play-Off SF 2nd Leg - Peterborough vs OUFC - Andrew Kitchen

[Northstandboy]

Vote now

 

[Sarge]

below average for me- more than a bit of a homer , 4

 

[Northstandboy]

Was a tough game to ref, we did do some “dark arts”.

 

[m]

I don't think he got a lot wrong at all.

 

[werthersoriginal]

I thought he went quite easy on considering all the fouling and stuff we were doing, certainly not a homer.

 

[Oxford84]

Not one single Peterborough player booked for any of the fouls, the handball or a couple of dives.

 

[RobOx7]

Not one single Peterborough player booked for any of the fouls, the handball or a couple of dives.

Who cares - we won!!

 

[Oxford84]

Who cares - we won!!

Well its the rate the ref thread so just giving my thoughts.

 

[RobOx7]

That’s fair enough - but seriously what Oxford fan is really thinking about the refs performance this evening

 

[Oufccraig45]

He was awful all round proformance posh fell over he gave them a free kick all night it's a 1 from me

 

[Chrisox]

Looks like we are at the Weat end of Wembley am I right in thinking that is end nearest the train station so we will be able to use the Green Man pub like we did in are conference play off.

 

[chuckbert]

Average for me. Didn't get many major things wrong, but there was something about how he managed the game that wasn't quite right. I can't quite put my finger on it, but just seemed a bit inconsistent compared to last week's official who was spot on.

 

[RobOx7]

Average for me. Didn't get many major things wrong, but there was something about how he managed the game that wasn't quite right. I can't quite put my finger on it, but just seemed a bit inconsistent compared to last week's official who was spot on.

Bit like payers at this level then - inconsistent!!

 

[chuckbert]

Bit like payers at this level then - inconsistent!!

Sure, but isn't he a championship ref?

 

[Berliner]

Average for me. Didn't get many major things wrong, but there was something about how he managed the game that wasn't quite right. I can't quite put my finger on it, but just seemed a bit inconsistent compared to last week's official who was spot on.

This is exactly what I thought, there's something about his body language that doesn't come over well...not sure what it is. I said that in a previous thread of his as well where he didn't manage the game well at all.

In terms of performance, I actually thought he was OK, by and large. All the big decisions he got right, bookings were OK for our side at least but he should have probably booked a few more Posh players (especially the handball for the penalty). And he kept the game flowing as best as possible, despite our glorious, glorious sh*thousery.

 

[SteMerritt]

Bit fussy, few soft decisions - both ways. Got the big calls correct, so guess that's all you can ask for.

 

[Foley]

This is exactly what I thought, there's something about his body language that doesn't come over well...not sure what it is. I said that in a previous thread of his as well where he didn't manage the game well at all.

In terms of performance, I actually thought he was OK, by and large. All the big decisions he got right, bookings were OK for our side at least but he should have probably booked a few more Posh players (especially the handball for the penalty). And he kept the game flowing as best as possible, despite our glorious, glorious sh*thousery.

He could have booked Rubin for dissent (many have done!) and a few of ours before Harris was a little unlucky to be the first booked.
So I think that he was a little lenient (like the previous ref to them when they kept fouling Murphy on Saturday)

 

[Marked Ox]

Bit fussy, few soft decisions - both ways. Got the big calls correct, so guess that's all you can ask for.

Agree with that. At least he gave the penalty!

 

[Oufccraig45]

Sure, but isn't he a championship ref?

Yes not much difference of between league 1 and the championship refs on that showing