• Further New Features Are Available - Click To Update
  • Join OxVox

    The forum would encourage all members to consider joining OxVox during this important moment in our history. See here for more information.

New Stadium The Triangle - Planning (S106 Agreed)

Once all of this has done and dusted meaning the stadium gets built, somebody should write a book about all of this??
RageOnline did a good recap on the Kassam stadium saga. A similar one would be a fantastic read.

I honestly think a book would be a brilliant thing, but please remember us football fans cannot read let alone write.
 
And this, for me, has always been the fundamental problem with Fosb

Their focus should have been the planning application. Full stop.

If they genuinely believed the stadium proposal was wrong on planning, environmental or transport grounds, then that should have been the argument from beginning to end. Challenge the evidence. Challenge the reports. Challenge the planning policy. Challenge the application.

But far too often it seemed to become something else entirely.

Every opportunity to have a swipe at Oufc was taken. Every difficulty at the club became another stick to beat them with. Finances, ownership, management, supporters somehow it all got dragged into a campaign that was supposedly about a planning application.

And that was their biggest mistake.

Because the more they attacked the football club itself, the more they undermined their own claim that this was simply about protecting Stratfield Brake/triangle and opposing one particular development.

It increasingly gave the impression that the real problem wasn't simply what was being built, but who it was being built for.

You cannot spend years insisting your campaign is purely about planning and then repeatedly use every available opportunity to have a pop at the applicant, the football club and, at times, its supporters.

That isn't scrutiny of a planning application. That starts looking personal.

And whatever faults Oxford United may have and there are plenty, because no football club is perfect one thing I think they got absolutely right was refusing to be dragged into the mud with them.

They could easily have turned this into a public slagging match.

They didn't.

They largely stayed quiet, allowed the planning process to run its course and, when they did speak publicly about FoSB, repeatedly invited them to engage.

That was the grown-up approach.

Imagine how different this whole debate might have looked if FoSB had accepted those invitations, sat around a table and seriously discussed mitigation, transport, ecology, community use and ways of improving the scheme.

Instead, we got years of confrontation.

And the irony is that the club they spent so much time attacking generally showed considerably more restraint towards them than they showed towards the club.

That's why I think FoSB ultimately damaged their own credibility.

You can oppose a stadium. You can challenge a planning application. You can take a council to court if you genuinely believe the law has been broken.

But once the campaign starts looking like an endless battle against Oxford United itself, people are entitled to question what the campaign was really about.

FoSB wanted everyone to believe this was only ever about the development.

Their own behaviour made that increasingly difficult to believe.
 
She always loses her campaigns against faceless corporations, she never had a chance against us.

If I was her I'd be packing my bags and moving well away. She is not very popular these days!
Apparently she lives in Hardboard Road near Cuttselowe Park, she’s a very brave lady, either that or plainly thick
 
And this, for me, has always been the fundamental problem with Fosb

Their focus should have been the planning application. Full stop.

If they genuinely believed the stadium proposal was wrong on planning, environmental or transport grounds, then that should have been the argument from beginning to end. Challenge the evidence. Challenge the reports. Challenge the planning policy. Challenge the application.

But far too often it seemed to become something else entirely.

Every opportunity to have a swipe at Oufc was taken. Every difficulty at the club became another stick to beat them with. Finances, ownership, management, supporters somehow it all got dragged into a campaign that was supposedly about a planning application.

And that was their biggest mistake.

Because the more they attacked the football club itself, the more they undermined their own claim that this was simply about protecting Stratfield Brake/triangle and opposing one particular development.

It increasingly gave the impression that the real problem wasn't simply what was being built, but who it was being built for.

You cannot spend years insisting your campaign is purely about planning and then repeatedly use every available opportunity to have a pop at the applicant, the football club and, at times, its supporters.

That isn't scrutiny of a planning application. That starts looking personal.

And whatever faults Oxford United may have and there are plenty, because no football club is perfect one thing I think they got absolutely right was refusing to be dragged into the mud with them.

They could easily have turned this into a public slagging match.

They didn't.

They largely stayed quiet, allowed the planning process to run its course and, when they did speak publicly about FoSB, repeatedly invited them to engage.

That was the grown-up approach.

Imagine how different this whole debate might have looked if FoSB had accepted those invitations, sat around a table and seriously discussed mitigation, transport, ecology, community use and ways of improving the scheme.

Instead, we got years of confrontation.

And the irony is that the club they spent so much time attacking generally showed considerably more restraint towards them than they showed towards the club.

That's why I think FoSB ultimately damaged their own credibility.

You can oppose a stadium. You can challenge a planning application. You can take a council to court if you genuinely believe the law has been broken.

But once the campaign starts looking like an endless battle against Oxford United itself, people are entitled to question what the campaign was really about.

FoSB wanted everyone to believe this was only ever about the development.

Their own behaviour made that increasingly difficult to believe.

Very well written and spot on. I think FoSB were hoping to get oufc dragged into a slanging match and say there you go typical football club dont care about community????. OUFC have given us all and inparticular FoSB a master class on taking the higher ground and just focusing on the planning application. In fact at the fans forum last september 2025, im not sure if it was Clarke mentioned that FoSB have done oufc a favour on the planning application with all of FoSB claims about the stadium proposal???.
 

Whilst the condescending, snooty reply is to be expected, he’s probably right. It’s the sort of thing he would oppose and there would be a record of it in the CDC portal somewhere. I’m not arsed to check.

However, because he’s facing a faceless corporate developer there, his criticisms aren’t played out in public. There’s no scrutiny or challenge to what he says and, even if there is, it’s not played out publicly on Nextdoor or Twitter.

He and the rest of FOSB simply never sought to understand what they were facing - a passionate support base (fan is short for ‘fanatic’ after all) who want the best for their football club and see that as being away from a stadium where our days out numbered as being tenants.
 
Whilst the condescending, snooty reply is to be expected, he’s probably right. It’s the sort of thing he would oppose and there would be a record of it in the CDC portal somewhere. I’m not arsed to check.

However, because he’s facing a faceless corporate developer there, his criticisms aren’t played out in public. There’s no scrutiny or challenge to what he says and, even if there is, it’s not played out publicly on Nextdoor or Twitter.

He and the rest of FOSB simply never sought to understand what they were facing - a passionate support base (fan is short for ‘fanatic’ after all) who want the best for their football club and see that as being away from a stadium where our days out numbered as being tenants.
Looking at the planning application for this development there is no objection from ian himself there is no ward objection in occ comments from himself
There's no objection from himself as cdc councillor
In total there is just 6 comments from the public
 
And this, for me, has always been the fundamental problem with Fosb

Their focus should have been the planning application. Full stop.

If they genuinely believed the stadium proposal was wrong on planning, environmental or transport grounds, then that should have been the argument from beginning to end. Challenge the evidence. Challenge the reports. Challenge the planning policy. Challenge the application.

But far too often it seemed to become something else entirely.

Every opportunity to have a swipe at Oufc was taken. Every difficulty at the club became another stick to beat them with. Finances, ownership, management, supporters somehow it all got dragged into a campaign that was supposedly about a planning application.

And that was their biggest mistake.

Because the more they attacked the football club itself, the more they undermined their own claim that this was simply about protecting Stratfield Brake/triangle and opposing one particular development.

It increasingly gave the impression that the real problem wasn't simply what was being built, but who it was being built for.

You cannot spend years insisting your campaign is purely about planning and then repeatedly use every available opportunity to have a pop at the applicant, the football club and, at times, its supporters.

That isn't scrutiny of a planning application. That starts looking personal.

And whatever faults Oxford United may have and there are plenty, because no football club is perfect one thing I think they got absolutely right was refusing to be dragged into the mud with them.

They could easily have turned this into a public slagging match.

They didn't.

They largely stayed quiet, allowed the planning process to run its course and, when they did speak publicly about FoSB, repeatedly invited them to engage.

That was the grown-up approach.

Imagine how different this whole debate might have looked if FoSB had accepted those invitations, sat around a table and seriously discussed mitigation, transport, ecology, community use and ways of improving the scheme.

Instead, we got years of confrontation.

And the irony is that the club they spent so much time attacking generally showed considerably more restraint towards them than they showed towards the club.

That's why I think FoSB ultimately damaged their own credibility.

You can oppose a stadium. You can challenge a planning application. You can take a council to court if you genuinely believe the law has been broken.

But once the campaign starts looking like an endless battle against Oxford United itself, people are entitled to question what the campaign was really about.

FoSB wanted everyone to believe this was only ever about the development.

Their own behaviour made that increasingly difficult to believe.

Top post. I’ve said in somewhere back in the 2000 odd pages here that I could have run a far, far better campaign ‘opposing’ the stadium without coming into so much conflict with the club and fan base.

Be consistent in what approach you’d take. Environmental grounds (without the need for Judy Webb’s bullshit, felt tip penned reports) and opposing any development on the green belt. Argue what’s the point of a green belt if it’s going to be developed on.

That was all lost in one moment when they tried to delay one of our meetings with OCC with a late consideration for a charity (whose name now escapes me) to potentially take on the site. It showed that they had no interest in the environmental aspects of it. It was all about who wanted it and for what.

Their campaign of hate is coming to an end. They could have been a player in this and potentially pushed for more community benefits as a critical skeptic of the project. As it, they’ll be in our rear view mirror soon enough.

For those who say to go after them with our lawyers, why bother? It’ll be an expensive distraction for no great purpose. It’s not like extracting anything from them would help get the stadium built. Living well is the best revenge and when the curtain raises on the stadium I intend to live very well indeed.
 
Last edited:
Looking at the planning application for this development there is no objection from ian himself there is no ward objection in occ comments from himself
There's no objection from himself as cdc councillor
In total there is just 6 comments from the public

Interesting. I wonder what ‘opposing since 2017’ means. Calling the Oxford Mail to say how opposed you are and doing the sum total of b****r all about it?
 
Top post. I’ve said in somewhere back in the 2000 odd pages here that I could have run a far, far better campaign ‘opposing’ the stadium without coming into so much conflict with the club and fan base.

Be consistent in what approach you’d take. Environmental grounds (without the need for Judy Webb’s bullshit, felt tip penned reports) and opposing any development on the green belt. Argue what’s the point of a green belt if it’s going to be developed on.

That was all lost in one moment when they tried to delay one of our meetings with OCC with a late consideration for a charity (whose name now escapes me) to potentially take on the site. It showed that they had no interest in the environmental aspects of it. It was all about who wanted it and for what.

Their campaign of hate is coming to an end. They could have been a player in this and potentially pushed for more community benefits as a critical skeptic of the project. As it, they’ll be in our rear view mirror soon enough.

For those who say to go after them with our lawyers, why bother? It’ll be an expensive distraction for no great purpose. Just keep a not like extracting anything from them would help get the stadium built. Living well is the best revenge and when the curtain raises on the stadium I intend to live very well indeed.
TRAX had been put forward as an alternative potential user of the Triangle. But the important bit is that TRAX’s trustees were subsequently reported as saying they had been told the Triangle was being considered specifically as a solution for Oxford United, rather than as land generally available for other organisations, and that TRAX had already “moved on” and was looking at other options.
 
Interesting. I wonder what ‘opposing since 2017’ means. Calling the Oxford Mail to say how opposed you are and doing the sum total of b****r all about it?
He means the local plan
the actual application for housing wasn't until 2022
Ian seems to think and he has done the same with exoq development because he opposed the local plan in 2017/18 his objection still counts

Oh and that 2017/18 objection went to a judicial review and lost so thats cherwell district council 3 Middleton nil
 
I do think when we win this as we all know we will, a letter to the fail from Mr Batt calling out Suzy for all these issues she has caused with appeal after appeal and the use of “ other people’s “ money to pay for it and make her look pathetic.
If she had tried once and accepted the outcome then fare enough but to keep trying is pathetic and maybe if Mr Batt could include Leigh Day as not acting in the best interests and use there experience to explain that FoSB are fighting a losing cause.
 
What it looks like to me is that FOSB has been used as a vehicle for certain local councillors to stay in she spotlight as opposition to a high profile development.
The problem is, this is big boy politics with big boy lawyers with lots and lots of money at stake. Yes, Oxford United have shown great restraint throughout, but this whole thing was too big for what I view as merely a minor protest group. They missed loads of obvious ways to oppose, because deep down I don’t think they ever really did.
 
You just know Suzanne will try and appeal, it's what she does, and there will be some toff on the Lathbury Road with more money than sense that will pay for it.

As frustrating as it is, that's exactly what will happen.

Fortunately, I no longer think it will make a difference.
 
What should happen now is that Middleton Mc Ivor and fellow councillors who have opposed the stadium should get in front of the media and say
“ We were against the stadium development but now have to concede it will go ahead, we will work closely with OUFC to get the best out of this project for Kidlington residents”
Because that is what Councillor should be doing , you don’t just represent the people who voted for you you represent the Community
They won’t do this of course they will take every opportunity to condemn the stadium from every lorry that trundles down the road during construction, to supporters turning up on match days they will complain and say in a really smug way “told you so”
These people will forever be our enemies, we need to combat them every inch of the way
 
What should happen now is that Middleton Mc Ivor and fellow councillors who have opposed the stadium should get in front of the media and say
“ We were against the stadium development but now have to concede it will go ahead, we will work closely with OUFC to get the best out of this project for Kidlington residents”
Because that is what Councillor should be doing , you don’t just represent the people who voted for you you represent the Community
They won’t do this of course they will take every opportunity to condemn the stadium from every lorry that trundles down the road during construction, to supporters turning up on match days they will complain and say in a really smug way “told you so”
These people will forever be our enemies, we need to combat them every inch of the way
5h1rhslbndrz.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom