• Further New Features Are Available - Click To Update
  • Join OxVox

    The forum would encourage all members to consider joining OxVox during this important moment in our history. See here for more information.

 Southampton spying on Middlesbrough

 
I’m glad Eckhart can continue as manager. The punishment is way, way over that of the crime. Demotion, fine, points deduction ….. Bloody hell, it was only some low paid employee with a pair of binoculars on a mission to see how the opposition might take a free kick. Football is not so marginal that anything can really be gained by this. It’s not so strategic that they can replicate exactly what they do on a training pitch into a match situation. You might be able to see how they set up but how many teams alter their formations on a match by match basis? I mean they spied on us and got beat 2-1, if ever there’s an argument to back this view up then that’s it.

Football has far more pressing issues than this nonsense.
 
I’m glad Eckhart can continue as manager. The punishment is way, way over that of the crime. Demotion, fine, points deduction ….. Bloody hell, it was only some low paid employee with a pair of binoculars on a mission to see how the opposition might take a free kick. Football is not so marginal that anything can really be gained by this. It’s not so strategic that they can replicate exactly what they do on a training pitch into a match situation. You might be able to see how they set up but how many teams alter their formations on a match by match basis? I mean they spied on us and got beat 2-1, if ever there’s an argument to back this view up then that’s it.

Football has far more pressing issues than this nonsense.
And the forum deserves better than this nonsense.

He threw young staff under the bus and the intent was that Southampton gained an advantage. Plain and simple cheating.
 
Last edited:
I’m glad Eckhart can continue as manager. The punishment is way, way over that of the crime. Demotion, fine, points deduction ….. Bloody hell, it was only some low paid employee with a pair of binoculars on a mission to see how the opposition might take a free kick. Football is not so marginal that anything can really be gained by this. It’s not so strategic that they can replicate exactly what they do on a training pitch into a match situation. You might be able to see how they set up but how many teams alter their formations on a match by match basis? I mean they spied on us and got beat 2-1, if ever there’s an argument to back this view up then that’s it.

Football has far more pressing issues than this nonsense.
Given that we are talking about an individual and football club actively cheating, what are the more pressing issues in your opinion?
 
I’m glad Eckhart can continue as manager. The punishment is way, way over that of the crime. Demotion, fine, points deduction ….. Bloody hell, it was only some low paid employee with a pair of binoculars on a mission to see how the opposition might take a free kick. Football is not so marginal that anything can really be gained by this. It’s not so strategic that they can replicate exactly what they do on a training pitch into a match situation. You might be able to see how they set up but how many teams alter their formations on a match by match basis? I mean they spied on us and got beat 2-1, if ever there’s an argument to back this view up then that’s it.

Football has far more pressing issues than this nonsense.

And the forum deserves better than this nonsense.

He threw young stuff under the bus and the intent was that Southampton gained an advantage. Plain and simple cheating.

As is diving to win a penalty. I’d love to know what you think Manchester City should get if sending a kid with a pair of binoculars to spy on Middlesbrough is worthy of this. In your opinion City will surely be demoted to L2, start that first season in L2 with a 100 point deduction and fined about £10 billion. I think City will very likely get just one demotion, probably a 20 point deduction and about a £5m fine. Given the relative wealth of each club it’s about the same as Southampton have got.
 
Given that we are talking about an individual and football club actively cheating, what are the more pressing issues in your opinion?

I’d be looking at the cheating in the Manchester derby for one. Yes, one man in a van in London can, I guess, in an unexplainable moment somehow misread a line on a screen but two or three people in that same van ? Come on, that’s billions to one that two or three people can misinterpret what is as clear as day in front of them - time, replays, angles, everything you want but the corruptness in this countries officiating shone through. Thats what I’d be looking at - we have the worst officials amongst all the powerhouse countries but we have the best product, an incredible imbalance but here we are fixated on a kid with a pair of binoculars earning himself a few quid overtime. 🙄🙄🙄🙄
 
I’d be looking at the cheating in the Manchester derby for one. Yes, one man in a van in London can, I guess, in an unexplainable moment somehow misread a line on a screen but two or three people in that same van ? Come on, that’s billions to one that two or three people can misinterpret what is as clear as day in front of them - time, replays, angles, everything you want but the corruptness in this countries officiating shone through. Thats what I’d be looking at - we have the worst officials amongst all the powerhouse countries but we have the best product, an incredible imbalance but here we are fixated on a kid with a pair of binoculars earning himself a few quid overtime. 🙄🙄🙄🙄

Please show your workings.

I’m glad Eckhart can continue as manager. The punishment is way, way over that of the crime. Demotion, fine, points deduction ….. Bloody hell, it was only some low paid employee with a pair of binoculars on a mission to see how the opposition might take a free kick. Football is not so marginal that anything can really be gained by this. It’s not so strategic that they can replicate exactly what they do on a training pitch into a match situation. You might be able to see how they set up but how many teams alter their formations on a match by match basis? I mean they spied on us and got beat 2-1, if ever there’s an argument to back this view up then that’s it.

Demotion? Did you make that up?
 
here we are fixated on a kid with a pair of binoculars earning himself a few quid overtime.

I think you're the only one fixated on 'the kid with the binoculars'.

No-one if suggesting throwing the book at him - he was clearly under instruction from above and was certainly naive but not the main culprit.

I'm not sure if you can understand this distinction.

We're talking about systematic premeditated cheating orchestrated by senior club management over a significant time that undoubtedly provided tangible insights that won them football matches.

Southampton are repulsive. And those who want to sweep it under the carpet are embarassing.
 
I’d be looking at the cheating in the Manchester derby for one. Yes, one man in a van in London can, I guess, in an unexplainable moment somehow misread a line on a screen but two or three people in that same van ? Come on, that’s billions to one that two or three people can misinterpret what is as clear as day in front of them - time, replays, angles, everything you want but the corruptness in this countries officiating shone through. Thats what I’d be looking at - we have the worst officials amongst all the powerhouse countries but we have the best product, an incredible imbalance but here we are fixated on a kid with a pair of binoculars earning himself a few quid overtime. 🙄🙄🙄🙄
You mention Man City’s cheating so let’s start with that, they cheated by financial doping which led to an unfair advantage on other teams. Now there is no certainty that they would win all the titles and competitions but it helps. If they had not been caught would they have carried on? I’d say so.

In doing so they have brought the game into disrepute and I believe the club should be kicked out of the league and those involved be banned from working in football.

Now let’s go back to the Southampton spy gate, they did this to gain an unfair advantage on their opponents, while there is no certainty that it will mean they win games, it will help them more times than not. Do you also honestly believe they only did it 3 times? I doubt it and if they weren’t caught would they carry on? I’d suggest they would.

The club got kicked out of the play offs, fined and a point deduction. IMO the man who organised it which brought the club and game into disrepute should have been banned from the sport for at least 12 months.
 
You mention Man City’s cheating so let’s start with that, they cheated by financial doping which led to an unfair advantage on other teams. Now there is no certainty that they would win all the titles and competitions but it helps. If they had not been caught would they have carried on? I’d say so.

In doing so they have brought the game into disrepute and I believe the club should be kicked out of the league and those involved be banned from working in football.

Now let’s go back to the Southampton spy gate, they did this to gain an unfair advantage on their opponents, while there is no certainty that it will mean they win games, it will help them more times than not. Do you also honestly believe they only did it 3 times? I doubt it and if they weren’t caught would they carry on? I’d suggest they would.

The club got kicked out of the play offs, fined and a point deduction. IMO the man who organised it which brought the club and game into disrepute should have been banned from the sport for at least 12 months.
Absolutely spot on. I agree City should be kicked out and all their trophy wins struck from the records. No asterisks and no runners up recognised as winners. Just their name struck through to remind everyone of the stain on the game.

As for Eckhert he should have had a 3 year ban from the game in this country.
 
I’m glad Eckhart can continue as manager. The punishment is way, way over that of the crime. Demotion, fine, points deduction ….. Bloody hell, it was only some low paid employee with a pair of binoculars on a mission to see how the opposition might take a free kick. Football is not so marginal that anything can really be gained by this. It’s not so strategic that they can replicate exactly what they do on a training pitch into a match situation. You might be able to see how they set up but how many teams alter their formations on a match by match basis? I mean they spied on us and got beat 2-1, if ever there’s an argument to back this view up then that’s it.

Football has far more pressing issues than this nonsense.

Football is incredibly marginal and advantages can be gained by despicable cheating methods.*


Corrected for you.
 
You mention Man City’s cheating so let’s start with that, they cheated by financial doping which led to an unfair advantage on other teams. Now there is no certainty that they would win all the titles and competitions but it helps. If they had not been caught would they have carried on? I’d say so.

In doing so they have brought the game into disrepute and I believe the club should be kicked out of the league and those involved be banned from working in football.

Now let’s go back to the Southampton spy gate, they did this to gain an unfair advantage on their opponents, while there is no certainty that it will mean they win games, it will help them more times than not. Do you also honestly believe they only did it 3 times? I doubt it and if they weren’t caught would they carry on? I’d suggest they would.

The club got kicked out of the play offs, fined and a point deduction. IMO the man who organised it which brought the club and game into disrepute should have been banned from the sport for at least 12 months.

I think I’m right in saying it is permissible to spy on a team but not within three days of a fixture - you can do all the spying you like on a Tuesday before a Saturday game but not on a Wednesday. So Eckhart got his timing wrong by a day, seems an incredibly harsh punishment for something that is legal one day but not the next. Apparently teams will work on the more intricate stuff in those three games, seems fair enough but also feels very weird to have denied a team promotion for getting the day wrong.
 
I think I’m right in saying it is permissible to spy on a team but not within three days of a fixture - you can do all the spying you like on a Tuesday before a Saturday game but not on a Wednesday. So Eckhart got his timing wrong by a day, seems an incredibly harsh punishment for something that is legal one day but not the next. Apparently teams will work on the more intricate stuff in those three games, seems fair enough but also feels very weird to have denied a team promotion for getting the day wrong.
What's really weird is you trying to defend the indefensible. The team was caught cheating and has been punished. The individual who sanctioned the cheating has been given a meaningless slap on the wrist. If people can break the rules and not be given an adequate punishment, it's hardly a deterrent to stop it happening again in the future.
 
What's really weird is you trying to defend the indefensible. The team was caught cheating and has been punished. The individual who sanctioned the cheating has been given a meaningless slap on the wrist. If people can break the rules and not be given an adequate punishment, it's hardly a deterrent to stop it happening again in the future.

It’s perfectly legal on a Tuesday but not on a Wednesday. As I say, seems incredibly harsh. If three VAR officials sitting next to each other can’t see a straight line on a TV screen then I’m prepared to forgive a bloke who might have got his Tuesdays and Wednesdays mixed up.
 
Last edited:
I think I’m right in saying it is permissible to spy on a team but not within three days of a fixture - you can do all the spying you like on a Tuesday before a Saturday game but not on a Wednesday. So Eckhart got his timing wrong by a day, seems an incredibly harsh punishment for something that is legal one day but not the next. Apparently teams will work on the more intricate stuff in those three games, seems fair enough but also feels very weird to have denied a team promotion for getting the day wrong.
To mix your days up 3 times (at least) is pretty unlucky isn’t it…
 
Except this isn't a discussion about VAR. The two aren't comparable

You obviously feel strongly about it - can’t say I am that bothered hence me saying I’m glad he’s continuing in management. But truthfully are you content that clubs are permitted to send spies to their opponents training bases, for a Saturday fixture, on the Tuesday but then risk relegation, suspended sentencing, thousands of pounds in fines and likely a life time of ridicule if they do it just hours later. Seems a ridiculous imbalance and a complete nonsense to me.

You’re at ease with another club setting up roadside at Horspath three days before we play them? What stops anyone flying a drone above a training centre? No club in the world owns the air space! In Germany (where Eckhart is from isn’t it?) it’s perfectly legal - as it is here up to 3 days before - to spy on another team any time you like. They aren’t daft enough though to make it illegal and hideously punishable if you get the wrong day. So what if you do it three times, bending the rules has been part of football for decades and there will be examples of manipulation of the laws of football across every single division this weekend and next weekend and the next, forever basically.
 
Last edited:
Well, quelle surprise, Man Utd fan whinging after having benefited from many years of dodgy decisions……

Decisions that were subjective in real time by one man NOT facts in front of a TV screen with the aid of every piece of technology you could wish for, no time limit and three men looking at it. Astonishing that you can’t spot the difference.
 
Last edited:
Football is incredibly marginal and advantages can be gained by despicable cheating methods.*

Corrected for you.

That’s nonsense. Football is marginal in terms of a decision but it’s not a marginal sport in terms of the general play. An individual sport requiring pinpoint accuracy - like snooker, golf or darts - is decided by fine margins. Lose the ball in midfield in football and, yes, it can of course lead to a goal but more often than not it’s lost in amongst the general play.
 
You obviously feel strongly about it - can’t say I am that bothered hence me saying I’m glad he’s continuing in management. But truthfully are you content that clubs are permitted to send spies to their opponents training bases, for a Saturday fixture, on the Tuesday but then risk relegation, suspended sentencing, thousands of pounds in fines and likely a life time of ridicule if they do it just hours later. Seems a ridiculous imbalance and a complete nonsense to me.

You’re at ease with another club setting up roadside at Horspath three days before we play them? What stops anyone flying a drone above a training centre? No club in the world owns the air space! In Germany (where Eckhart is from isn’t it?) it’s perfectly legal - as it is here up to 3 days before - to spy on another team any time you like. They aren’t daft enough though to make it illegal and hideously punishable if you get the wrong day. So what if you do it three times, bending the rules has been part of football for decades and there will be examples of manipulation of the laws of football across every single division this weekend and next weekend and the next, forever basically.
Do you think it’s right that someone with 35mg of alcohol per ml of breath is guilty of drink driving when someone with 34 mg is not. Seems a very draconian law when the difference is only a 3% increase.

Every law has a specification. Being on the wrong side of that law makes you definitively guilty. Being the other side doesn’t make you a moral saint.
 
Do you think it’s right that someone with 35mg of alcohol per ml of breath is guilty of drink driving when someone with 34 mg is not. Seems a very draconian law when the difference is only a 3% increase.

Every law has a specification. Being on the wrong side of that law makes you definitively guilty. Being the other side doesn’t make you a moral saint.

No one is saying they aren’t guilty. Being 1mg over drink drive will get you a soft sentence not having the book thrown at you - Southampton are the footballing equivalent and their punishment does not fit the crime, especially when the ‘crime’ is legal and not punishable just hours earlier.
 
Back
Top Bottom