• ****Join the YF Fantasy EFL League: HERE. ****

Current Player Marselino Ferdinan

Ferdinan.png
Marselino Ferdinan 🇮🇩

Signed
: 19th August 2024

 
Last edited:
No, it's not the 5th best league in the world because it just obviously isn't.
It totally depends on what you mean by 'best'. Our leagues do have good strength and attendances quite far down the pyramid, but that's not the same as saying the Championship is 'better' than all but three leagues outside England.
 
  • React
Reactions: m
It totally depends on what you mean by 'best'. Our leagues do have good strength and attendances quite far down the pyramid, but that's not the same as saying the Championship is 'better' than all but three leagues outside England.

I think you can make a good shout that England has the best, or at least one of the best football league systems from top to bottom in the world, we have the advantage of history (had a lot of years as the first country to do it to work on it), geography (the size of the country and ease of getting around are advantage over the likes of Brazil and the US) and demography (we have a decent sized population), obviously its a subjective opinion but the above factors added into the populations zeal for the sport and the attendances through out the pyramid do give an indicator. You certainly don't look at any other country and feel envious, all the regional leagues so high up in comparison to ours dilute the lower levels for me elsewhere, our set up seems the best.

No real evidence towards the view our second tier is pretty much an elite league though, which being fifth in the world very nearly make it, its a very good standard for the level it is but not quite where some people want to paint it.
 
Not remotely comparable.

South Korea and Japan have been regularly qualifying for World Cups for 40 and 30 years respectively (when it was an achievement to do so, too).

It's taken time for the top Koreans to playing for Bayern, PSG, Spurs and throughout the Bundesliga. Likewise Japanese players starting and excelling for top half PL sides.

By contrast, the Indonesian team is still largely made up of 3rd generation Indonesians who are Dutch born and raised, and have had (at best) modest careers at bang average Dutch or Belgian clubs.

You've just casually lumped countries together, it's no more useful than "you think of the quality of Colombian and Chilean players I think there’s no reason why Guatemala shouldn’t be next".

That's not to say that an individual can't break out from an otherwise 'lesser' footballing nation, but to suggest that Indonesia is on the cusp of producing a plethora of top talent any time soon is very wishful thinking.

It's also true that the youth coaching in Japan (and I assume South Korea as well), and professionalization of school sports is insane. Great facilities, high quality technical coaching and crazily popular - last year's All Japan High School Soccer Tournament finals had an average crowd of 7,634 (comfortably bigger than League Two).

They really established their youth setup in the 80s and 90s, and it's bearing fruit now.

China meanwhile threw a bunch of money at bringing top world talent to play at their clubs, but didn't put the same focus on youth coaching and sports - net result, their national team is still struggling and they have noone playing in a top European league.

I've no idea what they're doing in Indonesia right now, but there's a very clear roadmap for them as to what works and what doesn't. But it does take time.......
 
Not remotely comparable.

South Korea and Japan have been regularly qualifying for World Cups for 40 and 30 years respectively (when it was an achievement to do so, too).

It's taken time for the top Koreans to playing for Bayern, PSG, Spurs and throughout the Bundesliga. Likewise Japanese players starting and excelling for top half PL sides.

By contrast, the Indonesian team is still largely made up of 3rd generation Indonesians who are Dutch born and raised, and have had (at best) modest careers at bang average Dutch or Belgian clubs.

You've just casually lumped countries together, it's no more useful than "you think of the quality of Colombian and Chilean players I think there’s no reason why Guatemala shouldn’t be next".

That's not to say that an individual can't break out from an otherwise 'lesser' footballing nation, but to suggest that Indonesia is on the cusp of producing a plethora of top talent any time soon is very wishful thinking.

I didn’t say that Indonesian football is now the equivalent of South Korea and Japan , I said there’s no reason why Indonesia shouldn’t join them. And apart from some general abuse you haven’t offered any.

As I pointed out in my original post Indonesia is bigger than both the other two put together - tje 4th largest country in the world .

Two very wealthy Indonesians are doing their best to make Indonesia a footballing power so that in 20or 30 years time it will be where Japan or South Korea are today.

And Oxford United is a key part of their strategy- which is why the most exciting Indonesian talent ever is on our books
 
As i said from beginning in some of my posts, let him work to gain his ideal fitness and fight for get chances for play in team....step by step. FYI...since i am Indonesian and have watched his matches from U-17 U-19, U-23 and senior team, and in local club....what we saw in match against Saudi Arabia wasn't his best performance yet. At this moment i am happy because he only play for senior team...no more U-23 game. It will give him more times for recovery and can focus for club.

When coach and his staff see he is fit for the team...that because he deserve that. He will get there someday.

The league still have lot games to play league games, cup games, Des and his staff must be monitoring each players that deserve to play in team. With lot players in team they must be decided best eleven for each match, also need think about recovery, injuries players, etc

I don't think Des will extremely change the squad formation or tactic...if he needs to make rotation or some new players, he must be have strategy for that.

About Marselino position, IMO...if you remember Shinji Kagawa in his prime time with Dortmund, versatile AM, sometimes like false Nine....but that's only my opinion. Maybe you have different opinion.

Once again....so far everything seems on right track for this young man. Step by step gain hi ideal fitness, practice, learn, play for youth team, reserve team...and now only play for senior national team....he will get his chance someday, and that's because his hard work.

Most important...hope Lino still down to earth with current condition. Don't over confidence.

Have a good times and weekend for you all. May Oxford United always get good results.
 
Last edited:
Pub-based research led me to the song Bella Ciao.
Bella Ciao led me to songs sung by Liverpool 🤮 who stole it from Celtic 🤮 who (probably) stole it from Partick Thistle 🌵 and then the trail goes cold, but it probably goes back to Italian roots. The original song goes way back before that and appears in many languages. Our version for the Garuda Messi is obviously the best tho. Can't wait to hear it.
 
As i said from beginning in some of my posts, let him work to gain his ideal fitness and fight for get chances for play in team....step by step. FYI...since i am Indonesian and have watched his matches from U-17 U-19, U-23 and senior team, and in local club....what we saw in match against Saudi Arabia wasn't his best performance yet. At this moment i am happy because he only play for senior team...no more U-23 game. It will give him more times for recovery and can focus for club.

When coach and his staff see he is fit for the team...that because he deserve that. He will get there someday.

The league still have lot games to play league games, cup games, Des and his staff must be monitoring each players that deserve to play in team. With lot players in team they must be decided best eleven for each match, also need think about recovery, injuries players, etc

I don't think Des will extremely change the squad formation or tactic...if he needs to make rotation or some new players, he must be have strategy for that.

About Marselino position, IMO...if you remember Shinji Kagawa in his prime time with Dortmund, versatile AM, sometimes like false Nine....but that's only my opinion. Maybe you have different opinion.

Once again....so far everything seems on right track for this young man. Step by step gain hi ideal fitness, practice, learn, play for youth team, reserve team...and now only play for senior national team....he will get his chance someday, and that's because his hard work.

Have a good times and weekend for you all. May Oxford United always get good results.
Loving your posts. Please keep them coming
 
Bella Ciao led me to songs sung by Liverpool 🤮 who stole it from Celtic 🤮 who (probably) stole it from Partick Thistle 🌵 and then the trail goes cold, but it probably goes back to Italian roots. The original song goes way back before that and appears in many languages. Our version for the Garuda Messi is obviously the best tho. Can't wait to hear it.
Bella Ciao was a song of Italian partisans in the Second World War. My wife who’s learning Italian told me about it a while back
 
As i said from beginning in some of my posts, let him work to gain his ideal fitness and fight for get chances for play in team....step by step. FYI...since i am Indonesian and have watched his matches from U-17 U-19, U-23 and senior team, and in local club....what we saw in match against Saudi Arabia wasn't his best performance yet. At this moment i am happy because he only play for senior team...no more U-23 game. It will give him more times for recovery and can focus for club.

When coach and his staff see he is fit for the team...that because he deserve that. He will get there someday.

The league still have lot games to play league games, cup games, Des and his staff must be monitoring each players that deserve to play in team. With lot players in team they must be decided best eleven for each match, also need think about recovery, injuries players, etc

I don't think Des will extremely change the squad formation or tactic...if he needs to make rotation or some new players, he must be have strategy for that.

About Marselino position, IMO...if you remember Shinji Kagawa in his prime time with Dortmund, versatile AM, sometimes like false Nine....but that's only my opinion. Maybe you have different opinion.

Once again....so far everything seems on right track for this young man. Step by step gain hi ideal fitness, practice, learn, play for youth team, reserve team...and now only play for senior national team....he will get his chance someday, and that's because his hard work.

Most important...hope Lino still down to earth with current condition. Don't over confidence.

Have a good times and weekend for you all. May Oxford United always get good results.
good post bro
 

Key quote from that is:

"It’s now about him competing for spots with the other boys and if he continues to develop at the rate he has done since he arrived then I’m sure it won’t be long until he makes his debut."
 
I don’t think there are many sleeping giants left in international football, but Indonesia is one of them.

They have the three things you need if you want to make a go of massively increasing your standing in global football: a massive population, a strong national interest in football and lots of money.

Whilst China has 2/3, has Chinese football attracted a big passionate fanbase? I’d also argue Japan are successful in the exact model Indonesia want to replicate - let’s not forget there are NO Indonesian-born players playing in the top European leagues.

Indonesia has a population of 277.5m people, have a very passionate fanbase, and billionaires who are at the heart of the Indonesian football revolution. Marselino could be just the start of something big, and as a club we’re directly connected to that journey.
 
It's also true that the youth coaching in Japan (and I assume South Korea as well), and professionalization of school sports is insane. Great facilities, high quality technical coaching and crazily popular - last year's All Japan High School Soccer Tournament finals had an average crowd of 7,634 (comfortably bigger than League Two).

They really established their youth setup in the 80s and 90s, and it's bearing fruit now.

China meanwhile threw a bunch of money at bringing top world talent to play at their clubs, but didn't put the same focus on youth coaching and sports - net result, their national team is still struggling and they have noone playing in a top European league.

I've no idea what they're doing in Indonesia right now, but there's a very clear roadmap for them as to what works and what doesn't. But it does take time.......

China did throw money at Academies/youth football but they failed at how they were set up and how the Chinese coaches operate.

The coaching is mainly by repetition with everybody doing the same thing from a young age. This is good for basic skills but there is no individuality within the players so the play is predictable. Culturally it doesn't help either as kids are unlikely to have a kick around with their mates after school as parents will expect them to
I don’t think there are many sleeping giants left in international football, but Indonesia is one of them.

They have the three things you need if you want to make a go of massively increasing your standing in global football: a massive population, a strong national interest in football and lots of money.

Whilst China has 2/3, has Chinese football attracted a big passionate fanbase? I’d also argue Japan are successful in the exact model Indonesia want to replicate - let’s not forget there are NO Indonesian-born players playing in the top European leagues.

Indonesia has a population of 277.5m people, have a very passionate fanbase, and billionaires who are at the heart of the Indonesian football revolution. Marselino could be just the start of something big, and as a club we’re directly connected to that journey.

China also doesn't have the culture conducive to according to the English ex Director of Football (can't remember his name) who wrote an article on it (which I can't find at the moment). Their players tend to be very similar as they are pretty much coached using the same routines/paint by numbers approach.

The culture doesn't encourage individuality in play so players are scared to stand out and do something different.

This isn't helped as Chinese kids aren't likely to go for a kickabout after school as parents will expect them to focus on education. So an avenue for learning such skills where nobody cares other than to take the P**s is lost.

The change in attitude by the CCP won't help encourage this either.
 
What I love about Yellowsforum is that we can have pages of detailed discussion and debate about a topic, where members explain their reasonings for their opinions, and then someone comes along at the end to simply say ‘no is isn’t’.
Oh yes it is
 
I thought it would have been a good chance for Lino to get some minutes on Saturday.
Maybe if Scarlett hadn't made it 4-2 with 20 to go, giving us a slight chance, he would have came on for the last 20?
 
Back
Top Bottom