Having a bit of a statistics overload on this thread today.....
But here's Oxford's last five promotion seasons (and I haven't bothered to check how many were in the league, but assuming most):
2015-16 Leading scorer - Kemar Roofe (26)
2009-10 Leading scorer - James Constable (23)
1995-95 Leading scorer - Paul Moody (24)
1984-85 Leading scorer - John Aldridge (34)
1983-84 Leading scorer - Steve Biggins (24)
And the only other time we've ever reached the playoffs:
2006-07 Leading scorer - Rob Duffy (21).
Whilst accepting all the arguments that people are making about the game changing, and the importance of getting goals from all over the team - the fact is that it's been more than 50 years since OUFC has gained promotion or a playoff place without a 20 goal scorer!