You'd only get respect for a week or so until the players realise that knowing how to play the game and be an on pitch leader is completely different to managing and organising a team.I wouldn't mind John Terry someone like him would get respect from the players he's had a very successful playing career with lots of top managers. He's desperate to get into management so I think he would have fire in his belly to actually achieve something
Obviously it could be a complete disaster or it could be a real game changer for us
Either way Rowett pack your bags old boy and get out
He may well have that ability, but he hasn't proven it yet in the game beyond coaching and assistant roles. Given he's signed up to manager in the 'baller league' I would suggest his desperation doesn't apply to being good enough to interview and get jobs and plenty of management roles that have come up since he retired.
That may be due to him waiting until he feels he's ready, but personally I think we'd be foolish to put a completely unproven manager (and I think that's different from someone with 'Championship experience', which I don't think is as important as a lot here do) into a job this difficult.