For me, what last night really showed was that Gary Rowett has bet the farm on a single route to survival. He may be successful in that and I hope he is. But whether we survive or go down, many of our footballing receptors have been blunted as a result and will prove difficult to re-ignite. Is this improving our players? Have our most saleable assets had their development stalled because we’re so focussed on hitting that one key on the keyboard rather learning to type?
Previous managers – Chris Wilder, Michael Appleton, Karl Robinson and Des Buckingham have a common link in that they’ve had a transformative impact on players which became baked into the club. Tim Williams often talks about building the club’s maturity, layer upon layer, this approach doesn’t do that. He may argue there are other benefits, and he may well be right.
Rowett seems to have been brought in to achieve a short-term goal, he’s become more like a consultant with a context-free, highly simplified solution. He’s not there to become attached. This might be good for his brand, many managers sustain careers by becoming troubleshooters – Allardyce, Bruce, Warnock – and there are always struggling Championship and League One clubs who need a stabilising force, but whether it sets us up for a decent season in the Championship next season or an immediate promotion back from League One is open to debate.