As we are nearing the end of the season, thought it would be worth having a look if those we have on loan are worth keeping. Starting with Sinclair...
(this is just a quick look in comparison to others in the league with over 1000 minutes).
So....Jerome Sinclair:
View attachment 1325
This is off 1400 minutes, some of which at Sunderland.
Sinclair is performing pretty much in line with his xG however is shot volume is pretty poor...however this can be argued it is more a product of our playing style. He is pretty creative for a forward and fits our playing style in being effective at carrying the ball. Compare this to Mackie, who, as an attacking threat is very limited (should maybe compare aerial duels?):
View attachment 1326
Mackie takes just over 1 shot per match, and isn't hugely involved in build up with dribbles and passing.
Extending Sinclair's loan deal would be a good move, as in a short time he has shown to be a decent goal threat that can also create. Refine our playing style and he would be an asset on a season long loan.