Scotchegg
Level: James Constable
(280 Apps, 106 Gls)
- Messages
- 16,306
- Reaction Score
- 48,273
MApp was calmer on the sideline and spoke better after games when he won. But then Robinson also chilled out when we were getting results.So you don't think MApp's post match comments would be more sensible?
Or that he'd be calmer on the touchlines?
Or that MApp's team was no better organised than what we are watching week in week out?
All of those three are not 'sentimental guesswork' they are what happened when he was here!
It's a straw man argument to say what would he do with the players we've got. He isn't going to suddenly be our manager at this stage of the season, and if he was put in place earlier we would have different players.
And you don't think that he would have been able to attract better players in the first place?
Would he have signed Mackie? I very much doubt it.
Do you really think Robinson is actually getting the best out of the players he has? Because I certainly don't.
Some people choose to ignore the comments from MApp such as "plan B is going back to plan A" etc. He was a good manager but lets not ignore the fact that he was in charge of a team that had one of the top budgets in league 2. He had his failings too and wouldn't turn Mackie into Harry Kane or Garbutt into Roberto Carlos!!